In the winter I tend to watch boxing to fill the baseball void and it is no wonder that I decided to put together an all-time tough guy/fighter team and then create a new brawl chart with forfeits added. I selected the APBA card from the year of their most notorious incident or from the year that they had the most dust-ups.
The Brawl Chart:
I can send you a copy of the spreadsheet. It is modified from a version found on TableTop Sports to increase the likelihood of stare-downs and actual fights. I use the unmodified version for the Doormens' opponent, and the above for the Doormen.
The Tough Guys:
The Lineup:
C- Pudge Fisk from 1976
1B Kevin Youkilis from 2009
2B Rougned Odor from 2016
SS- Bert Campanaris from 1972
CF- Ty Cobb from 1911
RF- Albert Belle from 1996
DH- David Ortiz from 2005
The Rotation
1. Nolan Ryan from 1993
2. Roger Clemens from 2001
3. Pedro Martinez from 2003
4. Yolanda Ventura from 2015
The Bull Pen
Rob Dibble from 1991
Bench
Otis Nixon- 1991 Pinch Runner
A.J. Pierzynski - 2006 C
Billy Martin - 1958 Utility Infielder
Yasil Puig - 2014 OF
Coaching Staff
Manager John McGraw
Batting Order:
1. Pete Rose
2. George Brett
3. Ty Cobb
4. Albert Belle
5. David Ortiz
6. Carelton Fisk
7. Kevin Youkilis
8. Rougned Odor
9. Bert Campanaris
We might as well make this an over-the-top team. Hawk Harrelson calling the games.
Some scouting film on The Doormen: